PHP Frameworks Comparison Test

Frank Liu — Fri, 16 Jan 2009 15:22:49 +0000

We have done enough reading and digging on the net just to see how others test and compare PHP frameworks, however there are hardly anything recent and convincing. Most of the test are on throughput of a simple 'Hello World' page, which we don't think reflect the real performance of a framework, simply because no Database interaction was involved, hence Model as in MVC is not tested at all. So we decide to conduct our own test with a more real world case, which would require MVC work together intensively to get up the result.

The Test

We have each programmer picked a popular PHP framework, and the task is to setup the framework and create MVC for the benchmark, which involves,

1000 database insertion
1000 database update
query 1000 records (all fields), and display in a list
each record size is about 2kb

We then put all the coded project onto one work station which has the following configuration,

Pentium 4, 4.3GHz
2GB RAM
Windows XP, SP3
XAMPP 1.7.0 (patched to work with PDO)
APC enabled (Zend Optimizer disabled)
All programs turned off, including Anti-Virus and Firewall

We use a PHP batch script under CMD to make queries to each framework 10 times, and reports on the average response time and memory usage.

The Result

Framework	Database Engine	Avg. Response Time	Avg. Memory Usage
Pure PHP	mysqli	5.28s	0.14MB
oModel*	adodb mysql	7.13s	6.88MB
Yii Framework (yiilite)	pdo_mysql	7.41s	8.38MB
Yii Framework	pdo_mysql	7.7s	9.44MB
Kohana	mysqli	7.68s	11.22MB^#
Zend Framework	pdo_mysql	8.37s	7.99MB
Zend Framework	mysqli	11.28s	7.88MB
Akelos	mysqli	12.98s	10.93MB

* The Orite in-house lightweight MVC framework
# With parameter turned off in the database config file, it only uses 1.5MB memory, and takes about 7.8s. Thanks Jeremy Bush for the advice. (updated 24/07/2009)

The Verdicts

Framework	Pro.	Con.
oModel	Fastest framework, light file structure, highly flexible, real short learning curve	Not as comprehensive, not well documented, no community support, need high skill set to work on for large-scale project
Yii Framework	Fast, comprehensive, simple and secure file structure, strictly php5 OO, well documented, code generation	Farely new, still building community awareness
Kohana	Flexibility, Easy start	Big memory footprint, DB feature incomplete
Zend Framework	Great library set, flexible, best community support	Long learning curve, code generation problem*
Akelos	Great RoR port, database migration	Slow, php4

* We have try to run Zend-Tool on two workstations, all failed to run

The Conclusion

We understand this benchmark comparison is still bit off the real world, as it has too much emphasis on the database operation, where as in real web scenario the result can vary on different server deployment. Also, we didn't test cache mechanisms under each framework, which would play a real important role in the production environment, when server gets lot of hits on dynamic content, the result can be really different depend on project nature. Hopefully Orite will further test real web project taken most the core features of frameworks in consideration. If we were after speed, we would stick with oModel which had been the backbone of lots of recent Orite projects. After testing the frameworks, our team had picked both Zend Framework which has the most supportive community and feature set, and Yii Framework the good combination of comprehensive feature, ease of use and performance. We will start few project based on Yii Framework and continuously keep eyes and hands on Zend. Interesting findings regarding this topic will be posted after we have dived into these frameworks a bit more.

Searching for The PHP Framework

Frank Liu — Fri, 16 Jan 2009 02:57:34 +0000

Orite dev team have been working on our own MVC PHP dev framework for quite few years, which we utilize Adodb for database abstraction and TemplatePower for View template, and we have the handy oModel (Orite Model) to create all database tables as class objects, so all the database operations are nicely layed out in 3 layers. However we write our own Control, which consists of lots of inclusions (of classes and libraries) and dirty (not very readable) procedure logic etc. It's not too much of a hassle to develop on the Orite MVC framework, since the simplicity of it's structure and logic. However in order to do tricks like Ajax, URL rewriting, it requires all the knowledge about PHP MySQL HTML Javascript and Apache, and sometime because the different deployment environment one has to learn different platforms, we have been deploy on Linux (various distro), Windows (different versions) and Solaris. Although the Orite MVC framework performed for years, we decided to go something else. Since for the new year we are proposing few large-scale community portal sites, which would require more collabrative dev and constant maintenance. Here we set out the feature request for the framework we looking for which must have,

MVC pattern, since its what we familiar and happy with
No non-sense folder structure, not too flexible or too restricted
Solid and performance database abstraction layer, support transactions
Good error handling and reporting
URL management, routing and filtering
Layered theme, layout, view
Code generation
Strict PHP5 implementation
Good community support and active development
Easy learning and start
Performance and security

Would be bonus to have,

Templating
Ajax
Caching
Built-in useful libraries (validation, emailing, etc)
Shell support for cron jobs
I18n
Database migration

We know it's not an easy task to find THE right PHP framework to use and stick with, since there are quite few available on the market and all have quite good reputation. Also because the evolving of the technology and vary of our project scope. So we decide to firstly pick a few popular ones and do our own testing and benchmarking, that's the only way to choose properly. We'll follow up with the results... If you are using a PHP framework and think that's the best, please feel free to post a comment below.

Orite Blog » MVC

PHP Frameworks Comparison Test

The Test

The Result

The Verdicts

The Conclusion

Searching for The PHP Framework